
Both products come out of a spray gun and both seal air leaks. After that they behave differently enough that picking the wrong one costs you money — either by overspending on a job that didn't need it, or by installing foam that can't handle the conditions.
Here's how we choose between them on Hollywood, FL projects.
The short version
- Open-cell: about R-3.7 per inch, light and flexible, absorbs water, lower cost. Common on attic roof decks and interior walls.
- Closed-cell: about R-7 per inch, dense and rigid, resists water, acts as a vapor retarder at typical thickness, higher cost. Common on commercial decks, coastal exposure, cold rooms and tight cavities.
Where open-cell usually wins
For a typical Hollywood house with ducts in the attic, open-cell on the roof deck brings the attic inside the envelope at the lowest cost per square foot. It's also easier to trim and inspect, and if a roof leak ever happens, water passes through rather than hiding behind rigid foam — which sounds bad but actually makes the leak visible sooner.

Where closed-cell is worth the premium
- Coastal and flood-prone areas near the Intracoastal and the beach, where materials may get wet
- Thin assemblies — flat roofs, shallow plenums, 2x4 walls — where you need R-value per inch
- Metal roof decks in warehouses, where condensation control matters
- Cold rooms such as coolers and wine rooms that need vapor control
- Crawl spaces and block wall interiors where moisture is present

Things that are true of both
- Both air-seal, which is often the bigger comfort win in a leaky Florida house
- Both generally need an approved thermal or ignition barrier under the Florida Building Code
- Both require the space to be vacated during application and for a manufacturer-specified re-entry period
- Both perform only if applied at the right thickness — ask for measurements, not just a price
Cost comparison
On a roof deck, open-cell typically runs $2.20–$3.80 per square foot installed and closed-cell $3.50–$6.50. Closed-cell reaches a target R-value in less thickness, but it rarely costs less overall. Detailed numbers are in our Florida insulation cost guide and the Boca Raton pricing example.
Questions worth asking any contractor
- Which product and brand, and what thickness?
- What R-value does that thickness deliver?
- What thermal or ignition barrier are you using, and is it listed with that foam?
- How long before we can re-occupy the space?
- Will you provide thickness photos or measurements?
Still unsure? We'll look at the building and tell you which one we'd use and why — including when the answer is neither, and blown-in would serve you better. See spray foam for Hollywood homes, commercial spray foam in Hollywood, or our spray foam insulation service. Background reading: Department of Energy — Types of Insulation.
Illustrations by Standard Insulation. Photos: Standard Insulation project photos from our Google Business Profile.




